The Critical Guide to
the Warren Illustrated Magazines
1964-1983
by Uncle Jack
& Cousin Peter
![]() |
Kenneth Smith |
"The Thing in Loch Ness" ★★1/2
Story and Art by Bruce Jones
"Skipper's Return!"★1/2
Story and Art by Ernie Colon
"The Final Ingredient!"★1/2
Story and Art by Bill DuBay
"Prelude to Armageddon" ★★1/2
Story by Nick Cuti and Wally Wood
Art by Wally Wood
"Extra Censory Perception" ★★1/2
Story by Steve Skeates
Art by Gary Kaufman
"A Tangible Hatred" ★★
Story by Don McGregor
Art by Rich Corben
![]() |
Yep, that's The Beast From 20,000 Fathoms, all right! |
His bright idea is to lay fake tracks along the shore and craft a phony monster (which he powers underwater by cables!) to attract pub-goers. The trick works and soon the lovers are rolling in enough dough to get them to America. First, for some reason, Jerald decides he has to go to the bottom of the Loch and dismantle his monster gizmo. Unfortunately for the dopey American, the real thing rears its head and, as he's heading for the surface, Jerald becomes entangled in the anchor around the dead guy and gets eaten by Nessie.
![]() |
"Skipper's Return!" |
A chimpanzee is sent out into space aboard a rocket ship destined for Jupiter, but it somehow becomes smart enough to return the spacecraft back and get a little revenge on its keeper. The rigors of decoding an Ernie Colon story continue with "Skipper's Return!" I'm not one of these dunderheads that has to have all the art sectioned in nice little panels, but Colon's stories are nigh-unreadable (there are images of dissected frogs intermingled with half-completed human faces) and the text is added almost as an afterthought. The twist, with the intelligent ape returning to Earth, worked much better in Escape From the Planet of the Apes.
![]() |
"Prelude to Armageddon" |
Equinus, messenger of the Gods (who just happens to be a Centaur) is hanging out at the falls one day when he spies a gorgeous (and nekkid) bathing beauty. Suddenly, from out of the skies, come the "winged demen," creatures with bad ideas on their minds, and the Centaur and his new squeeze are forced to flee. The girl is harmed and Equinus snatches her up, barely making it back to the safety of his city of Irith. The babe can't talk, so our hoofed hero christens her "Melody." Equinus explains to the girl that he was on a mission to Cirius Gorgoroth, where dwells the beastly Blud and his right-hand monsters, Karion and Minos Taurus. A lot of battles ensue, Melody is brutally murdered by a zombie (don't ask) and, eventually, the world as Equinus knows it ends.
I've had it up to here trying to synopsize these goofy Sword and Sorcery/Fantasy/Whatsits with their pick-'em-out-of-a-hat character names and endless treks to cities I can't pronounce. Seriously, all you need to know is... Wally! I think the splash page may have been kept under the mattress of more than one pre-teen in the day. Wood's art is simply amazing, his women are beyond gorgeous, but it seems as though each new script is a Xerox of the last. This here guy goes on a trek, meets a babe with big boobs, kills monsters with his big sword (nothing subtle about that), and conquers the evil fiend who's holding the kingdom in his bloody grasp. I will say that "Prelude to Armageddon" has an interesting finish; I won't say that I thought it was satisfying.
![]() |
"Extra Censory Perception" |
"Extra Censory (sic) Perception" starts out as an on-the-nose indictment (I've always wanted to use that word) of watchdogs and how they foist their own morals on the populace. I'm sure Steve Skeates had his problems with the funny book censors during his career (he's the closest in vibe I've ever encountered to Michael Fleisher... and that's a huge compliment) and this was a little revenge. For the most part, it works, but its abbreviated length (an extremely rare Warren five-pager) torpedoes the narrative in the end and the exaggerated finale is a little silly.
![]() |
"A Tangible Hatred" |
![]() |
"Creepy Fan Club" |
Jack-Peter, you're right on the money with the Corben story. It seems endless at ten pages and the only thing I liked was Corben's monster. His art style is completely wrong for the sections of the story that are police procedural. "The Thing in Loch Ness" was overly wordy and got off to a slow start, but it gained power as it went along. More a short story with illustrations than a good comic book story, it's the best thing in the issue. Wally Wood's busty women are the highlight of the otherwise nearly unreadable "Prelude to Armageddon," and "Extra-Censory Perception" is heavy-handed but has that striking Gary Kaufman art. Bill DuBay's "The Final Ingredient!" edges out Colon's unfocused "Skipper's Return!" mainly due to the humor in DuBay's narrative.
![]() |
Sanjulian |
"Isle of the Huntress!"★★★★
Story by Archie Goodwin
Art by Jose Gonzalez
"The Wedding Gift"★★
Story by Nick Cuti
Art by Mike Ploog
"The Sword of Light"★1/2
Story and Art by Sam Glanzman
"Deadman's Treasure!"★★★
Story by Lynn Marron
Art by Tom Sutton
"Wolf Hunt"★★★1/2
Story by Joe Wehrle
Art by Esteban Maroto
After spending three days on a raft drifting at sea, Vampirella and Pendragon land on an island, where she tells her companion that she's almost out of serum and so they'd better separate for his own good. They are apart only briefly for, as soon as Pendragon is alone, he is set upon by a werewolf and must be rescued by his scantily-clad gal pal. Also on the island are Jean, a buff, shirtless scientist, and Vivienne, his inamorata, who likes to lounge in bed in her nightie. Hearing the commotion in the jungle, they investigate and find the werewolf dead, Vampi flying off in bat form, and Pendragon left to explain. Just then, a plane crash-lands on the island and out of it steps none other than Adam Van Helsing, searching for shipwreck survivors and one in particular.
![]() |
"Isle of the Huntress!" |
Jean injects Adam with a serum and Vampi escapes Vivienne. Next morning, the serum has worn off and the lady from Drakulon has a powerful hunger. Pendragon knocks Jean out with a blow from behind and lets Adam loose, just in time for an attack by Vivienne the werewolf. Silver bullets from a handy gun don't faze her, but in flies Vampi and the battle is on! Not surprisingly, Vampirella kills Vivienne and drinks her blood; Jean also turns into a werewolf, having accidentally fallen on his own syringe, and the silver bullets work just fine on him. With his dying words he reveals that he was working on creating a creature able to kill Vivienne, since she wanted to die and end the carnage. Adam and Vampi hope to find peace together, if only his father would back off!
I think I'm enjoying the continuing Vampirella series more than anything else we've read in the Warren mags to date. Goodwin is writing solid, old-fashioned hero comics with a tinge of monsters and horror, and Gonzalez's art is superb. I like the way they pulled bits and pieces from other classic horror stories to cobble together this tale set on a jungle island.
![]() |
"The Wedding Gift" |
First, the good--Mike Ploog's art is very pleasing to the eye and he joins the list of Warren artists who can draw sexy women very well. Now, the bad--Nick Cuti's script is a mess and the ending comes out of left field. Still, the art is good enough that I can excuse the flaws in the story.
![]() |
"The Sword of Light" |
Incredibly, we survive 7+ years of DC War Comics and countless, dreadful stories by Sam Glanzman, only to encounter him in a Warren Horror Mag! In "The Sword of Light" he plays to his strengths, which do not include depictions of the human face. It's amazing how many ways Glanzman can lay out a page in order to avoid drawing faces as much as possible. When he does, they're ugly, as usual. But he draws a nice queen and the full-page illo (reproduced here) where she slices Yekkun in two is gruesomely cool.
![]() |
"Deadman's Treasure!" |
I would have given this story four stars back when Tom Sutton was the brightest light at Warren, but with the overall improvement in quality and the presence of the Goodwin-Gonzalez team in this same issue, I used relative grading and awarded it three stars. As a Fredric Brown fan, I'm always up for a good carnival tale, and this one does not disappoint, though Sutton's depiction of Ernie makes him barely human.
![]() |
"Wolf Hunt" |
As impressed as I am with the art of Jose Gonzalez on the Vampirella series, I'm even more dazzled by this story drawn by Esteban Maroto, whose pages are tremendous. His style has echoes of that of Ernie Colon, but he's a better storyteller and less prone to confusing page designs. Peter and the people who comment on our posts have long promised good things from the Spanish artists and I'm thrilled to see it coming true.-Jack
Peter-"Isle of the Huntress!" is a boatload of coincidences. What are the odds Vampi ends up on the same island as a werewolf? And then, how the heck did Adam find that little island? But, most of all, I want to know... did the Crimson Chronicles make the bestseller list in 1971? Seems like everybody and their hunchbacked henchman read this one. I love Archie Goodwin and I'm liking the Vampi character, so I really want to get into this series, but it's not working yet. "The Sword of Light" answers the question no one asked: Does Sam Glanzman, belittled by your hosts so many times over on the DC War posts, draw a nekkid woman with the same efficiency he does a haunted tank? Well, I do have to say I like Sam's stuff here better than over there, but it still isn't fantastic. The story is confused and boring.
Cuti's "The Wedding Gift" seems almost unfinished but, no worries, Mike Ploog makes the tiny words negligible. "Deadman's Treasure!" is a lot of fun (and yes, I know it's a bit choppy and makes very little sense), the kind of swamp story EC would run (in fact, big Ernie Johnson sure looks like a nod to Jack Davis) and Tom Sutton is aces here. Esteban Maroto makes a stunning debut with "Wolf Hunt," a gorgeous feast for the eyes. Overall, another attractive package from Vampirella.
![]() |
Enrich Torres |
"Bad Moon on the Rise!"★★1/2
Story by Doug Moench
Art by Tom Sutton
"The Silence and the Sleep"★★
Story by Steve Skeates
Art by Jose Rubio
"Prototype"★★
Story by Steve Skeates
Art by Bruce Jones
"Look What They've Done!"★★
Story by Steve Skeates
Art by Esteban Maroto
"Crocodile"★★
Story by Don Glut
Art by Jose Antonio Perez Mascaro
"The Trap"★★★
Story by Greg Potter
Art by L.M. Roca
"Oh, Brother!"★★1/2
Story by Steve Skeates
Art by Dave Cockrum

In spite of the corny CCR references, this story is kind of fun, and Tom Sutton's entertaining art helps a great deal. The tale ends on a question: Cousin Eerie suspects that the werewolf will return to life at the next full moon but, if that's true, what about in an hour when the lunar eclipse is over? I need to know!
Concert pianist John shoots and kills the man his girlfriend Joyce is two-timing him with. Joyce goes into shock and is admitted to a mental institution, while John has a nightmare in which police grab him and take him to a concert hall, where he plays random notes on a piano. Later, the police show up at his door and find his typed confession; it seems that, when he thought he was playing his piano in the dream, he was really typing out a detailed account of the murder.
![]() |
Colon+Grandenetti=Rubio ("The Silence and the Sleep") |
If this story weren't credited to Jose Rubio, I'd think it was the work of Ernie Colon, with a little bit of Jerry Grandenetti weirdness thrown in for good measure. Unlike many of Colon's stories, though, the narrative is fairly coherent, even if the whole thing is a bit dumb.
![]() |
"Prototype" |
Not a bad story, but Jeff Jones's art looks unfinished, as if Warren published pencils that were never inked.
In "Look What They've Done," a hippie revolutionary realizes he's trapped in a comic book story and refuses to fight the space monsters sent to take over his planet.
![]() |
"Look What They've Done!" |
In the jungles of Brazil, natives kill crocodiles both for the purse and luggage trade and for crazy Dr. Kracilik, who is trying to create a missing link by injecting crocodile serum into unfortunate natives. When the doctor decides to use a native named Jose as his next subject, Jose turns the tables and injects the doctor, who quickly turns into a "Crocodile." He slithers into the swamp, where he is soon killed by natives to make another purse.
This isn't a bad story, it just doesn't go anywhere particularly surprising. The doctor wants to make a missing link? Why? When he gets his just desserts, it's as expected, and there is no suspense created between when he loses his human form and when he is butchered.
![]() |
"The Trap" |
It's rare that I read an Eerie story and wish it were longer, but that was the case with "The Trap." The influx of artists from overseas is wonderful and Roca's style is impressive, with his use of deep blacks and grays. The end was a surprise as well, which is equally rare.
![]() |
"Oh, Brother!" |
"Oh, Brother!" is a good title for another hokey tale by Steve Skeates, who seems to have a talent for stating the obvious. Fortunately, Dave Cockrum's art is sharp and he's already showing signs of growth. I wonder how serious things would have gotten in 1971 if you put Doug Moench, Steve Skeates, and Don McGregor together in the same room for a rap session. Heavy, man.-Jack
Peter-Well, that's a pretty cool cover, but it doesn't look like a wolf's paw to me. "Bad Moon on the Rise!" is a cute and gimmicky bit of nonsense and those of us old enough to remember Creedence will smile at all the references (although Susie Q dropping John Fogerty's name in the swamp made no sense at all to me). The twist at the climax is a good one as well. Heck, anytime Doug Moench can write a werewolf tale and not make it some metaphor for the Republican Party is all right by me. "The Silence and the Sleep" is just awful, another script that makes very little sense coupled with barely-average graphics. "Prototype" comes off like a failed Sub-Mariner TV pilot and Bruce Jones's usually fine work looks like a portfolio rather than a cohesive whole.
![]() |
"Crocodile" |
![]() |
Sanjulian |
"The Quaking Horror" ★★1/2
Story by Gardner Fox
Art by Rafael Auraleon
"A Change of Identity!"★1/2
Story by Don Glut
Art by Dave Cockrum
"The Amazing Money-Making Wallet"★
Story by Steve Skeates
Art by Joe Staton
"Spacial Delivery" ★★★
Story by R. Michael Rosen
Art by Larry Todd
"A Chronicle!"★
Story by Steve Skeates
Art by Jorge Badia Romero
"Escape From Nowhere World"★
Story by T. Casey Brennan
Art by Jerry Grandenetti
"Ice Wolf" ★★
Story and Art by Gary Kaufman
![]() |
"The Quaking Horror" |
In "A Change of Identity," Gradvitz the werewolf is hunted down and shot with silver bullets but, just to make sure he doesn't return from the dead as a vampire (or so the local legends say), the villagers run him through with a stake for good measure. Enter Trogg, the local put-upon hunchback, who's tired of being whipped and beaten simply because he's different. He unspikes Gradvitz and makes him an offer: turn the hunchback into a strong werewolf in order that he may wreak havoc on his tormentors and he, in turn, will safeguard the new vampire's coffin. Gradvitz agrees and Trogg sets up house, but the vampire has an ace up his sleeve. He pulls out a voodoo doll and strangles Trogg, transforming him into a zombie. Hoo-Ha, got us, didn't he? Ol' Don Glut pulled a switcheroo on us... the werewolf is actually a vampire and the hunchback is actually a zombie! Cockrum's monsters and the fact that this type of tale is preferable to fairies and unicorns is all that kept my interest.
![]() |
"Spacial Delivery" |
An alien crash-lands in the swamp adjoining a small European village and begins his search for an element needed to fix his vehicle. Unfortunately for the hapless outer-space man (who can change shapes at will), he's become stranded in a village full of religious fanatics convinced their little town has a werewolf problem. One of them sees him transform into a wolf in the forest and hilarity ensues. "Spacial Delivery" is a fun little romp with a sharp sense of humor and some stirring graphics by Larry Todd, moonlighting (for the second and final time in Warren history) from the Todd/Bode duo. Check out the detail in that panel above! This comes off as a prelude to the nuttiness Rich Corben would very soon provide on an almost-monthly basis.
![]() |
An inspiration for half of Bruce Springsteen's material, perhaps? |
Perhaps still gripping the bowling trophy he won for "On the Wings of a Bird" (way back in Creepy #36), T. Casey Brennan settled in front of his typewriter with a heavy sigh and attempted to write a sequel of equal if not heavier breadth. "How can I possibly top (admittedly) a masterpiece?" sighed Brennan. "Perhaps I should do what I did the first time and not give it much thought!" And so was born "Escape From Nowhere World," a tale that somehow achieves an even greater apex of pretension than its predecessor. Back are Ahzid and his stone friend in the middle of the desert. Joining them this time is a pretty maiden who happens upon the pair just as Ahzid is awakening from a two-centuries' long nap. What follows is a string of psychobabble dialogue and a directionless plot.
Ahzid: No! Please, great statue! There has to be some other way! There has to be! Please!
Statue: If I must die let it be as a man who can feel and love and care and hope--not as a great cold stone monstrosity! And if I must die, let it be for the ideals for which I once lived! Let it be my final victory over the forces of oppression...
It boggles my mind that anyone could have read either Brennan story and mistaken it for great literature. As David Lee Roth once famously said, "There's a sucker born every minute!"
![]() |
"Death, where is thy release?" |
![]() |
Staton! |
Jack-Best in Show this time around goes to Rosen & Todd's "Spacial Delivery," a clever and enjoyable mix of Gothic and alien themes. Next is "The Quaking Horror," in which Auraleon's fine art elevates another tired Fox story. "A Chronicle!" wastes four pages of sharp art by Romero on a terrible script, while "Ice Wolf" is ten pages long and well-drawn but, again, weak on the story front. I'm sensing a trend with Warren. I like Dave Cockrum's art so didn't mind "A Change of Identity," despite another mediocre Glut story, while my excitement at seeing one of Joe Staton's first pro credits in "The Amazing Money-Making Wallet" is dampened by more poor work from Skeates. Gotta love Staton's hippie chick, though, as well as the depiction of the melting man. Worst of all is "Escape from Nowhere World," which has uninspired graphics by Jerry G. and pretentious claptrap trying to pass for a narrative.

(Tempo Books, .75c)
164 pages
"Sand Doom"
(Reprinted from Creepy #5)
"Overworked"
(Reprinted from Creepy #2)
"Untimely Tomb"
(Reprinted fromCreepy #5)
"Vampires Fly at Dusk!"
(Reprinted fromCreepy #1)
"Werewolf!"
(Reprinted from Creepy #1)
"Grave Undertaking"
(Reprinted from Creepy #5)
"Curse of the Full Moon!"
(Reprinted from Creepy #4)
"Collector's Edition"
(Reprinted from Creepy #10)
Though promised as the first in a series, Tempo Books'The Best of Creepy was the one and only mass-market paperback of Warren comic material to appear while the company existed. I found mine in a B. Dalton's in late 1971 before the ads started appearing in the zines. Back in the day, it was actually possible to be surprised about something you found at the bookstore (of course, now there aren't any bookstores left) and I was thrilled by my discovery and snapped it up immediately. The reproduction isn't that great and (in the tradition of the EC paperbacks published by Ballantine in the 1960s) two or three panels sideways per page isn't the ideal way to read something like Frazetta's "Werewolf."-Peter
![]() |
From Vampirella 14 |
![]() |
From Eerie 36 |
![]() |
From Creepy 42 |
![]() |
Next Week... Don't look now but... Here Come the 80s! |